Follow Kritica on Google
Add Kritica to your favourite sources.
Quando Laura Schuyesmans, consigliera comunale dei Verdi di Gand, parla della politica degli appalti della città e degli scambi commerciali di prodotti israeliani e dalle colonie illegali in Cisgiordania e Gerusalemme Est occupate, sostiene che l’adozione di un “divieto commerciale sugli insediamenti” è il modo più efficace per fare di Gand una città che applica i principi fondamentali dei diritti umani ed il diritto internazionale.
“Quello che abbiamo adottato è interamente inquadrato nell’ottica di una politica di appalti basata sui diritti umani” spiega. “La stessa logica che applichiamo alle pietre che usiamo per i nostri marciapiedi, che acquistiamo solo da fornitori certificati come esenti dal lavoro minorile. Vogliamo fare lo stesso con i prodotti alimentari, i farmaci, tutto ciò che acquistiamo: all’interno di questo quadro, i prodotti provenienti dagli insediamenti israeliani illegali in Cisgiordania e a Gerusalemme Est semplicemente non passano.”
The press immediately called it a boycott. Ghent did not deny it. But on its own channels, the city uses only one term: commercial ban on settlements. The framing makes a political difference, but what matters here is the legal outcome.
Gand's first move dates back to November 2023, when the City Council declared that human rights must be at the core of all procurements. The local government was tasked with developing a concrete clause to give real weight to this declaration. When Schuyesmans was elected in 2024, she found the clause not impactful enough. In September 2025, the City Council approved a new, much stricter one. Indeed, Gand does not merely exclude products from illegal settlements. The scope is extended to all Israeli companies that profit from the occupation, including businesses within Israel that invest in settlements or participate in other forms of economic involvement with the occupation and genocide. “It's a ban on all Israeli companies that profit from and are complicit in the occupation,” says Laura.
Questa distinzione è fondamentale, dirimente. Limita l’espediente che rende i nostri mercati pieni di prodotti che attarversano le frontiere dell’Unione: non solo quelli provenienti dagli insediamenti illegali nella Palestina occupata, ma tutti i beni al di fuori dei territori occupati la cui filiera produttiva o il cui portafoglio di investimenti rimane legato ad essi. Basa inoltre le politiche adottate non sulla geografia, ma sulla complicità, che è il punto verso cui il diritto internazionale umanitario si orienta sempre più.
The challenge of verification
Putting these decisions into practice is no easy task, and Schuyesmans does not downplay the complexities. Products from the settlements entering Belgium first pass through Israeli customs, and product codes may be obscured or altered by intermediary companies. “I wouldn’t say that the city of Ghent is 100% safe, or even 99% safe, nor that we no longer have any problems,” he admits, “but we are doing our best with a range of organisations and partners.” It is a question of political will.
Ciò che Gand ha costruito è un sistema di verifica a più livelli. La città lavora con elenchi di codici a barre e codici prodotto che identificano le merci di origine palestinese, che vengono attivamente promossi e prioritizzati, mentre i codici associati a “flagged-zones” sono trattati come tali, e approfonditi caso per caso . Un team legale interno monitora continuamente i fornitori. Esperti palestinesi con una conoscenza dettagliata delle aziende e società israeliane, partecipano direttamente al processo di verifica delle provenienze e complicità. Vengono consultate le banche dati ONU delle aziende coinvolte. Perché queste esistono e sono accessibili a tutti. E la città mantiene un dialogo aperto con i fornitori: per scuole, ospedali e le strutture pubbliche di Gand, viene chiesto di dimostrare che la catena produttiva sia in regola rispetto all’interdizione di lavoro minorile, di prodotti degli insediamenti e sulle violazioni di quelle sul commercio equo. Se questi criteri non sono dimostrabili o applicabili, la città cerca un’alternativa. Le complessità sono evidenti: esistono prodotti utilizzati dalla polizia o da migliaia di funzionari pubblici e per trovare un’alternativa ci vuole tempo ed impegno, e in questo tempo i differenti settori interessati non possono rimanere scoperti.
Four sectors are considered high-risk and are rigorously monitored: food, pharmaceuticals, IT, and transport. Companies are not simply blacklisted (or green-listed) and forgotten. Monitoring is continuous, as ownership structures change. Laura cites the example of a fair-trade textile supplier acquired by an Israeli company, which neither the city nor the supplier had foreseen. “Ownership can change, sometimes without the supplier being entirely aware.” Russian dolls, but ones that can be opened.
A framework for fair, sustainable and inclusive procurement for all
Perhaps the most transferable insight from Gand's approach is precisely the fact that the settlements clause is not standalone, in its own right. It is embedded within the city's already existing framework for fair, sustainable and solidarity-based procurement: the city organises fair clothing sessions for hospital staff, construction materials free from child labour, and circular economy standards.
Oxfam, where Schuyesmans works full-time as Campaigner for Rights in Crisis, plays a fundamental supporting role: it prepares toolkits for municipalities, organises training for municipal procurement officers and participates in the advisory committee that directly informs procurement decisions. The effect is to normalise the clause on settlements, making it an application of already operational principles, rather than an exceptional political act that could provoke legal disputes.
The right-wing parties on the council (N-VA and Vlaams Belang, ed.) were the ones to raise legal concerns and vote against the measure. The liberals in the coalition were initially hesitant but were convinced precisely because of this framing: this is not about a boycott, but about applying international law and human rights to public procurement and purchasing policies.
International law exists: let's use it
When procurement managers or suppliers contest the measure, Schuyesmans's response is direct: “Here is the law.” The illegal status of Israeli settlements under international law, repeatedly confirmed by the International Court of Justice and reiterated in UN resolutions, is not a political position but a legal fact. Ghent is not expressing a moral judgment; it is applying existing international humanitarian law to its own contractual decisions. EU regulations themselves already require products from settlements to be labelled distinctly from Israeli goods when sold to consumers. Ghent is simply taking this existing legal distinction and applying it to its own supply chain, then extending it to companies whose economic involvement goes beyond the settlements themselves.
From Ghent to a national ban
Quanto adottato dal Consiglio comunale di Gand si è propagato a macchia d’olio. La città di Liegi ha seguito. Poi Mons. Poi altre città nelle Fiandre e in Vallonia. Le città che non hanno ancora agito in questa direzione contattano Gand per richiedere la documentazione, cauti nel vedere se emergeranno battaglie legali prima di impegnarsi. Quando non emergono, dice Laura, il messaggio è chiaro: “Questo è il nostro momento.” Il sindaco di Gand, che presiede la Network Eurocities, a platform connecting over 200 European cities, has also presented the clause at informal occasions to the various EU municipalities that are part of the network, with concrete examples on its implementation and hosting visits from municipal delegations wishing to observe the procurement mechanisms firsthand. The most significant development, however, could be at the national level. Belgium appears to be heading towards an official ban on settlement products at a national level which, considering the current political composition of the federal government, Laura considers potentially transformative. “If Belgium does it, and everyone knows we have a rather right-wing prime minister, I think it could have a domino effect in other EU countries.”
Structural work
The trade ban on settlements is, Schuyesmans insists, precisely the sort of concrete structural measure that complements street protests without replacing them. It is less visible than a demonstration, less noticeable in the news cycle. But it transforms supply chains, puts pressure on suppliers, establishes replicable legal models and, above all, enshrines the ending of complicity as a standard function of city government, rather than as a radical exception. “It’s less high-profile. But it really does make a difference.”
© Kritica – Riproduzione parziale consentita (non più di metà articolo) citando la fonte e inserendo il link all’inizio.
PHOTO CREDITS: Lucio Arisci


1 Comment
Pingback: "Rome knows where to stand”, the Gualtieri administration not yet - kritica